Order Openly vs Square for Restaurants

Square is a broad POS with a $0 plan and published processing rates. Order Openly is a hosted ordering and reservations storefront with flat monthly pricing.

Disclosure: this site is run by the makers of Order Openly. Last checked November 18, 2026.

POS
Order Openly: Partial

Manager, Hostess, Kitchen, and hardware packages on the public site. Card readers are not offered yet.

Square for Restaurants: Yes

Free, Plus, and Premium plans.

Reservations
Order Openly: Yes

Built in.

Square for Restaurants: No

No native reservations. Integrates with OpenTable and other booking apps.

Gift cards
Order Openly: Claimed

Claimed on the public Compare to Toast page. No dedicated public product page was found this check.

Square for Restaurants: Yes

Digital and physical. Up to 2.5% load fee plus processing on purchase. No extra fee to redeem.

To-go ordering
Order Openly: Yes

Pickup and delivery settings: times, addresses, minimums, fees.

Square for Restaurants: Yes

Branded ordering page included, even on the $0 plan. No Square commission.

Delivery
Order Openly: Partial

Courier set up in onboarding. Courier dispatch in the public demo is simulated.

Square for Restaurants: Yes

Pickup and local delivery, including on-demand couriers such as DoorDash and Uber.

Loyalty
Order Openly: Preview only

Not generally available. Preview only, unpublished, and off for every restaurant.

Square for Restaurants: Yes

Square Loyalty. Monthly software price not confirmed this check.

Customer data
Order Openly: Yes

Payments go to the restaurant's own Stripe account. Guests can order with no account.

Square for Restaurants: Partial

Square processes payments and holds customer profiles in Square.

Monthly fee
Order Openly: Hosted: Mesa $799/mo, Cocina $999/mo, Casa $1,299/mo. Custom website embedding: Ask for pricing.
Square for Restaurants: Free $0/location. Plus $49/location. Premium $149/location. Cancel or switch anytime. 30-day trial on Plus and Premium.
Processing
Order Openly: No Openly cut. The restaurant pays Stripe. The public compare page cites Stripe's standard US rate of 2.9% + 30¢.
Square for Restaurants: Free: 2.6% + 15¢ in person, 3.3% + 30¢ online. Plus: 2.5% + 15¢ / 2.9% + 30¢. Premium: 2.4% + 15¢ / 2.9% + 30¢. Custom rates may be available over $250,000 a year.
Hardware
Order Openly: Upfront packages: Mesa $1,995, Cocina $4,795, Casa $6,795.
Square for Restaurants: Sold separately. Reader from $59; Stand $149; Terminal $299; Handheld $399; Register $899; Kiosk about $1,999 with countertop stand. Financing available.
Contract
Order Openly: The written agreement controls. No standard term length published.
Square for Restaurants: No long-term contract on published Square plans.
Per-order commission
Order Openly: $0 platform commission on the restaurant's own sales.
Square for Restaurants: $0 commission on Square online orders.

Where Order Openly wins

  • Built-in reservations. Square has no native reservations and integrates with OpenTable and others.
  • Payments go to the restaurant's own Stripe account. Square is the processor.
  • Bilingual English/Spanish and split payments by link or QR in one storefront.

Where Square for Restaurants wins

  • Far lower software price: Free $0, Plus $49, Premium $149 per location.
  • Square sells card readers and full POS hardware. Order Openly does not offer card readers yet.
  • Published in-person rates (as low as 2.4% + 15¢ on Premium) can beat Stripe's 2.9% + 30¢ standard US rate.
  • Live gift cards and loyalty. Order Openly loyalty is preview only and off.
  • No long-term contract on published Square plans.

Bottom line

Square is the easy, low-cost choice for an in-person register. Order Openly is a different purchase: a branded ordering and reservations storefront. Many restaurants comparing the two should price Square plus a reservations tool against Order Openly's flat package.